This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, SmarterHomeGardens.com earns a small commission on qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Hydroponic gardening, the art of growing plants without soil, offers a range of advantages for growers of all skill levels. With the ability to carefully control nutrient levels and environmental factors, hydroponics can lead to many benefits like increased yield, and healthier plants. However, one critical decision for those looking to start a hydroponic garden is whether to set it up indoors or outdoors.
Whether growing plants hydroponically indoors or out, both options come with their own unique benefits and challenges that can significantly influence your growing success. Ultimately, you should make your choice based on your budget, available space, desired crops, and personal preferences.
In this article, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of each method. If you have the space and budget for it, indoor hydroponics can be a great way to grow plants year-round. If you are looking for a more affordable option, outdoor hydroponics can be a good choice. Let’s dive in.
Outdoor vs. Indoor Hydroponics
Outdoor hydroponics
| Outdoor Hydroponics Advantages | Outdoor Hydroponics Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Natural light | Weather dependent |
| Space for larger systems | Limited control over environmental factors |
| Lower initial investment | More pests and disease |
| Natural pollination | Greater wear and tear on equipment |
Indoor hydroponics
| Indoor Hydroponics Advantages | Indoor Hydroponics Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| More control over environmental factors | Higher initial investment |
| Year-round growing capabilities | Dependence on artificial lighting |
| Reduced pests and disease issues | Limited space for larger systems |
| Reduced pest and disease issues | Dependence on artificial lighting |
A brief overview of hydroponics
Before we dive deeper into this article let’s make sure we all understand the basics of what hydroponics is exactly.
Simply put, hydroponics is an innovative form of growing plants without the need for soil.
Read my article: Hydroponic Towers: What are they and how do they work?
Instead, plants are growing using a nutrient-rich solution made from carefully balanced nutrients designed specifically for hydroponic plant growth. The plant’s roots are usually supported by an inert medium such as perlite, coconut coir, or rock wool. can you introduce the
The importance of choosing the right hydroponics system
There are many different types of hydroponics systems out there. Before you read further, I’d advise you to read the article linked above and consider carefully which type of system is best suited for your individual needs.
Comparing outdoor vs. indoor hydroponics systems
Most hydroponics systems can be operated indoors or outdoors. Each environment, however, has its own advantages and disadvantages. Personally, I like to take advantage of both – positioning my hydroponics systems (which I purchased from Vertical Horizon) indoors during the winter and fall and moving them outside in the spring and summer.
The next section of this article will delve into the advantages and drawbacks of each environment, equipping you with the knowledge to determine the best hydroponic environment for your specific needs and aspirations.
Outdoor Hydroponics: Advantages
One of the aspects of gardening I enjoy the most is spending time outdoors. In addition to enjoying the warm sun on your face and a cool breeze on your skin while gardening, a more natural environment can have several other advantages for hydroponics growth.
1. Natural Sunlight
The sun is an abundant source of free light that (when it’s shining) is perfect for plant growth. Not only is it free, but sunlight contains a very wide spectrum of light, which is just what plants need for photosynthesis.
Artificial lights by comparison usually contain only a limited number of light waves meaning plants are not able to photosynthesize as effectively.
Check out this related article: Do Hydroponics Systsmes Need Sunlight to Work?
2. More space for larger hydroponics systems
Another advantage of having your hydroponics system outside is that you are less likely to be constrained by space. This, of course, depends on the amount of outside space you have at your disposal.
But in general, you are less likely to be constrained by rooms and ceilings outside which, if you so desire, will allow you to establish a larger hydroponics system.
Check out my related article: Best place to position your vertical garden.
3. Lower initial investment
Another big advantage of establishing your hydroponics system outdoors is that you can leverage free resources like sunlight, and therefore reduce the need to purchase expensive artificial lights. Similarly, those growing outside won’t need to buy any ventilation systems like oscillating fans.
Here, the elements are your ally. But, remember, they can also be your greatest enemy!
In any case, setting up a hydroponics system outside generally requires a less expensive kit designed to re-create naturally occurring environmental factors.
4. Natural pollination of plants
Natural pollination in an outdoor hydroponics system is the process of transferring pollen from the male part of a flower (the stamen) to the female part of a flower (the pistil) by wind, insects, or other animals. This process is necessary for plants to reproduce and produce fruit.
Outdoor hydroponics systems benefit from all of these processes naturally, whereas plants growing in indoor hydroponics systems often need to be pollinated artificially (i.e., with human intervention).
Outdoor hydroponics: Disadvantages
There are, however, disadvantages to growing plants hydroponically outdoors. I’ve listed the main ones I’m aware of below:
1. Dependency on the weather
One of the major drawbacks of outdoor hydroponics is its reliance on weather conditions. Hydroponic systems outdoors are subjected to the whims of nature, including variations in temperature, rainfall, and sunshine, which can negatively affect plant growth and health.
Fluctuations in temperature can disrupt nutrient uptake, while excess rain can dilute nutrient solutions, leaving your plants malnourished.
2. Limited control over environmental factors
When hydroponic systems are set up outdoors, you have less control over critical environmental factors like humidity, light, and temperature. Inconsistent lighting can lead to uneven growth, while unstable temperatures and humidity can hinder optimal plant development.
Without the climate control offered by indoor hydroponic setups, outdoor growers must adapt their systems to the prevailing weather conditions, which can be time-consuming and challenging.
3. Pests and disease are more of an issue
Outdoor hydroponic systems are more exposed to pests and diseases compared to their indoor counterparts. Pests like aphids, spider mites, and caterpillars, as well as diseases such as powdery mildew and root rot, can be problematic for outdoor growers.
While some degree of pest and disease management is possible, the lack of a controlled environment makes it difficult to protect your plants entirely.
4. Greater wear and tear on equipment
Outdoor hydroponic systems are also subjected to harsher environmental conditions that can cause increased wear and tear on equipment. Prolonged exposure to sunlight can cause UV degradation of plastic components, while strong winds and rain can corrode metal parts.
As a result, outdoor systems may require more frequent maintenance and replacement of parts, leading to higher operational costs.
You can learn how to properly maintain a hydroponic tower system in my other article.
Indoor hydroponics: Advantages
Indoor hydroponics carries many advantages over growing plants outside. And, in my view, rings closer to what hydroponics is all about. Here are a few such advantages:
1. Complete control over environmental factors
Indoor hydroponics provides a distinct advantage in that it allows for complete control over environmental factors such as light, temperature, and humidity.
With indoor systems, you can use artificial lights to ensure consistent illumination, while temperature and humidity can be controlled with heating and ventilation systems.
It’s even possible to create a hydroponics system that’s able to grow plants in a room with no windows. This precise control facilitates optimal growing conditions for your plants and enables them to flourish.
2. Year-round growing capabilities
One of the major benefits of indoor hydroponics is the ability to grow plants year-round. Regardless of the season or outside weather conditions, you can cultivate crops indoors without interruption.
This capability allows for a steady supply of fresh produce and the opportunity to diversify your crop selection throughout the year.
3. Better control over pests and diseases
Indoor hydroponic systems offer better protection against pests and diseases compared to outdoor setups. By controlling the growing environment, you can minimize the risk of infestations and diseases.
Check out my related article: Preventing and Removing Mold in Hydroponics: The Ultimate Guide.
Additionally, by employing good sanitation practices and closely monitoring your plants, you can promptly address any issues that may arise and safeguard the health of your crops.
4. Space-saving solutions
Indoor hydroponics offers space-saving solutions ideal for urban or small-scale growers. Vertical farming, stacking, and tiered systems enable you to maximize your growing space, making it possible to cultivate more plants in a smaller area.
This efficient use of space is especially valuable for those with limited room to dedicate to gardening.
Indoor hydroponics: Disadvantages
But it isn’t all plain sailing. There are a number of disadvantages which I have listed below. Depending on your space and situation, you may also want to consider the health and safety implications of indoor hydroponics.
1. Higher initial investment and running costs
Indoor hydroponic systems can be more expensive to set up and maintain than their outdoor counterparts. The initial investment includes the costs of artificial lighting, temperature, and humidity control systems, and grow medium.
Check out my article: How much electricity does a hydroponics system use?
In addition, the ongoing expenses of electricity and regular equipment maintenance can add up over time, making indoor hydroponics less cost-effective for some growers.
2. Limited space for larger hydroponics systems
Indoor growing often means limited space, which can restrict the size of your hydroponic system. While space-saving solutions like vertical farming can help maximize your growing area, there are still limitations to how much you can grow in an indoor environment.
This limitation may make it difficult for those looking to scale up their operations or grow larger plants.
3. Limited opportunities for natural pollination
Indoor hydroponic systems can struggle with natural pollination, as they lack access to pollinators like bees and butterflies. This limitation can affect the yield and quality of certain crops, such as fruits and vegetables that rely on cross-pollination.
While manual pollination is possible, it can be time-consuming and less effective than natural pollination.
4. Dependency on more costly artificial lights
Indoor hydroponics relies heavily on artificial lights, which can be more expensive to run than utilizing natural sunlight. These lights are essential for plant growth but can increase your energy bills.
Moreover, selecting the appropriate spectrum of light for your plants can be a challenge, as different crops may require different light conditions for optimal growth.
Depending on the lights and other environmental control systems used, indoor hydroponics systems can be quite noisy and may disturb you (depending on where the system is located in your home).
What are the best plants to grow on a hydroponic tower?
Whether you’re cultivating plants indoors or outdoors, success hinges on having the appropriate setup to meet each plant’s specific needs. I’ve authored a comprehensive article detailing my top 10 best plant choices for hydroponic tower gardens.
However, the possibilities extend far beyond that limited list. Here, I offer an additional 54 plants for you to explore—some may pose more of a challenge, but that’s all part of the gardening journey.
To sum up
The decision of whether to opt for outdoor or indoor hydroponics is largely dependent on your specific needs, goals, and available resources.
Outdoor hydroponics offer the benefit of natural sunlight and a larger growing space, but are subject to the unpredictability of weather and increased pest and disease exposure.
Conversely, indoor hydroponics provide complete control over environmental factors and year-round growing capabilities but come with higher costs and space constraints.
Ultimately, both options have their merits and drawbacks, and the best choice will be influenced by factors such as your budget, available space, desired crops, and personal preferences.
By carefully weighing the advantages and disadvantages of each, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your objectives and enables you to reap the benefits of hydroponic growth.
Good luck! Let me know how you get on!